culinaryadventure.online

Sharing is caring!

The Fluffernutter Sandwich is a nostalgic New England recipe, good for a particular lunchbox maintain. Candy, creamy, and sudden, it’s a scrumptious shock everybody will love!

This submit may embrace affiliate hyperlinks. See my disclosure safety for particulars.

With as soon as extra to highschool season beginning (and Nationwide Fluffernutter Day arising in October), I needed to get a recipe out for busy mothers to assist make lunchtime a bit additional candy. 

And inside the event you’re from New England (notably rising up in Maine and Massachusetts), then I do know you’ve put down a number of fluffernutters in your day. 

These sandwiches are a necessary a part of childhood! 

Now that I’m a mother, I truly like having the chance to share this huge easy nostalgic maintain with my kiddo and yours!

These fluffernutter sandwiches are easy and quick and are good packed alongside some carrot sticks, path combine, and salty seasoned popcorn.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• With merely three components and three minutes, you will have a beautiful express sandwich that the youngsters can’t resist.
• These sandwiches are versatile. Swap out the peanut butter for nut butter or photograph voltaic butter to meet your loved ones members’s wants.
• Fluffernutters are far more pleasing than a typical peanut butter and jelly sandwich.
• That is such a satisfying shock to sneak contained in the lunch topic. It’s an ideal lunchtime maintain the youngsters will LOVE.
• This standard recipe will carry you appropriate as soon as extra to your childhood. 

Substances You’ll Want For A Elementary Fluffernutter Sandwich

• Tender Sandwich Bread– White bread is the conventional bread for a fluffernutter. The softer the higher. I just like the thick sliced sandwich bread for simpler consuming.
• Peanut Butter – Creamy peanut butter or chunky works correctly. The white bread and marshmallow fluff add as loads as a candy sandwich, so the salty peanut butter will assist steadiness that out.
• Marshmallow Fluff – I would really like actual “Fluff” vs Marshmallow Creme. Solely due to that’s what I grew up with and it’s made appropriate correct proper right here in New England.

Step-By-Step Directions

If you may make a peanut butter and jelly, chances are high you will make a fluffernutter! This fluffernutter recipe is the fitting decision to jazz up easy peanut butter sandwiches.

Step 1:

Lay out your objects of bread and accumulate the Fluff and peanut butter.

Step 2: 

Unfold one slice of bread with peanut butter after which unfold the second slice with marshmallow fluff.

Step 3: 

Press the 2 sandwich halves collectively and reduce them in half. Have the benefit of instantly or wrap up and pack in a lunchbox for later!

Extreme Suggestions For Greatest Fluffernutter Sandwich:

For among the many best peanut butter and fluff sandwiches, listed beneath are among the many best methods I observed from making fairly a number of of those sandwiches.

• Don’t add an excessive amount of peanut butter. I truly like peanut butter, however it’d actually overwhelm the marshmallow type.
• Everytime you lower the sandwich in half, shield the 2 halves collectively if you wrap it. The fluff tends to leak out over time. Retaining the sliced edges collectively avoids a big quantity!

Substitutions:

• Nut butter or photograph voltaic butter is more likely to be swapped for peanut butter.
• Swap white bread for gluten-free bread, wheat bread, multigrain bread, or any sandwich bread you may have gotten accessible.
• If you happen to can’t uncover Fluff model marshmallow fluff, you will swap in Jet Puffed Marshmallow Creme. The marshmallow creme merely has additional stabilizers than customary fluff.

Variations:

The sky is the restrict for this pleasing and easy sandwich. Regulate the amount of peanut butter type, marshmallow or add pleasing mix-ins like these beneath:

• Change out the peanut butter for Nutella for a chocolatey marshmallow maintain.
• Add sliced fruit like bananas or strawberries to the peanut butter layer for extra sweetness and dietary nutritional vitamins.
• Use a sandwich cutter to make handmade uncrustables with peanut butter and fluff. These are good to make upfront and take care of household adventures with out your entire mess!
• Drizzle the Fluff aspect of the bread with strawberry jam or blended berry jam
• You presumably can swap customary Marshmallow Fluff for strawberry flavored Fluff for extra deliciousness.

Grilled Fluffernutter Sandwich

If you wish to grill this scrumptious sandwich, I terribly encourage that.  The bread will get golden brown and crispy and the fluff and peanut butter get melty, heat, and gooey. It’s primarily most likely probably the most nice maintain (and late-night snack)!

Make the sandwich as instructed above. Butter all sides of the bread and place the sandwich onto a scorching skillet over medium-high or medium warmth (relying in your stovetop).

Grill the sandwich for two minutes on one aspect, then flip and toast the second aspect for 1 minute till golden brown and melty. Cut back in half and expertise!

Storage:

Fluffernutter sandwiches are greatest saved tightly wrapped in plastic (the marshmallow does ooze out the lower sides) in a lunch topic or at room temperature for as loads as eight hours.

If you happen to’re meal prepping for the week, I want to advocate wrapping any uneaten sandwiches tightly contained in the fridge. Ahead of consuming, let your sandwich come as loads as room temperature.

Serving Choices:

Serve your Marshmallow Fluff sandwich alongside some kettle cooked potato chips and veggies. For one issue additional substantial, attempt it with my air fryer french fries!

FAQs

If you happen to make this recipe, give it a 5 STAR Ranking and Depart a Remark!

Extra As soon as extra To College Recipes

Sharing is caring!